|Search this Thread|
|28th May 2015, 11:42 AM||Custom bone weights to Milkshape? #1|
Hello guys, it's me again.
I have a question concerning bone weights in general. I have troubles to rig some meshes I made, especially skirts. I tried a lot of reference meshes to copy the bone data from, but none of them worked for my meshes... Picture below shows my struggle:
So I exported in Milkshape to Blender via the ms3d script and finally had the armature file and the vertex groups in Blender and started repainting the weights. Well, I took a look at the weights from EA, they look kinda... weird... But I thought well, that's maybe the export from Milkshape that messed up the data... See what I mean: weird bone weights for the belly bone ehem
Especially the thigh, spine and breast bones were incorrect, so I focused on repainting them.
After repainting the bones quickly I exported back to Milkshape (I exported with the blender to ms3d export script). And after opening in Milkshape, I had no more joints or bone weights. Yay. I tried 3ds and fbx export too, but I loose my weights everytime
Anyone ideas how to get the bone data to Milkshape? That would be a huge step forward for me. Rigging new meshes from scratch is way better then transferring bone data from existing meshes...imao. I see so many meshes that get fucked up in game due to false rigging. Has anyone the same problems?
Thanks for everything guys
|28th May 2015, 1:06 PM||#2|
You can do manual joint weighting in Milkshape using the Joints tab or the UniMesh Bone Tool, but I don't know how to fix your Blender problem, sorry.
What I lack in decorum, I make up for with an absence of tact.
|28th May 2015, 3:22 PM||#3|
Thx for replying :*) Milkshape can only assign weights to selected verts as far as I know. The result is always ugly clipped rigging and unreal looking mesh distortions. No 'smooth' weights. Like they can be drawn in 3ds or Blender ( What exactly is the unimesh bone tool?
|3rd Jun 2015, 4:49 PM||#4|
You can assign fractional weights to selected vertices in Milkshape, so smooth weighting CAN be done. I haven't used Blender but maybe it's easier. According to the documentation for the Blender MS3D plugin, it doesn't do joints.
|12th Jun 2015, 11:43 AM||#5|
Oh noo there is no way around Milkshape, a nightmare. Sorry for the noob question, but are joints and bones the same? Is there a way to import joint/bone/whatever-data into Milkshape via common file types like fbx, dae etc.? I guess not, otherwise someone else would have already done this. I'm always wondering how ppl can 'ruin' their meshes (esp. dresses and skirts) with bad weights... asakldnhaskldfj
I mean I started as a total noob, now I'm somehow able to make my own meshes, proper uvs and stable textures BUT weighting is still a huge problem... especially for 'extraordinary' meshes. Ugh.
I'm very uncomfortable with Milkshape... I did some custom meshes for Skyrim, Dragon Age and Fallout and the weighting was not a big deal. I painted the weights in Blender or 3DS Max and this was a 10 min thing. Now I have to mess with Milkshape again oh lord, my faith is leaving me :'//////////////////
|11th Feb 2019, 8:24 AM||#6|
Join Date: Sep 2014
Hi, what is the script used to export from milkshape to blender? Thanks